FROM CIRCULAR ECONOMY INITIATIVES TO CONSERVATION OUTCOMES: A CRITICAL REVIEW AND MULTILEVEL GOVERNANCE FRAMEWORK FOR RESOURCE, WASTE, AND BIODIVERSITY TRANSITIONS
Keywords:
circular economy, conservation governance, biodiversity safeguards, regional policy, resource efficiency, waste prevention, sustainability transitionAbstract
Circular-economy policy has expanded rapidly, yet its practical success is still commonly judged through recycling, investment, or project counts rather than verified reductions in resource pressure and ecological harm. This critical review updates the governance-oriented analysis of circular-economy initiatives in Andalusia with 32 recent Scopus-indexed records spanning regional policy, manufacturing, consumption, tourism, agri-food systems, infrastructure, finance, social enterprise, and waste management. A structured narrative synthesis was used to compare problem definitions, causal mechanisms, methods, outcomes, and transferability. The evidence shows that circular transition is strongest when five functions operate together: binding direction, coordinated delivery, demand-side participation, finance and infrastructure, and transparent outcome monitoring. Policy fragmentation, weak targets, limited data comparability, and the marginal treatment of biodiversity remain persistent constraints. Firm-level studies identify management commitment, reverse logistics, skills, technology, and customer demand as important enablers, but frequently stop at organizational performance. Regional studies reveal that normative pressure, absorptive capacity, and public-private investment shape adoption, although ecological additionality is rarely tested. We therefore propose a multilevel conservation-governance framework that connects circular inputs and practices to intermediate changes in material flows and then to climate, pollution, habitat, and distributional outcomes. The framework distinguishes process indicators from outcome and safeguard indicators, preventing recycling gains from being mistaken for absolute sustainability. It also embeds spatial differentiation, social inclusion, rebound-risk assessment, and adaptive monitoring. The review concludes that circular economy can support conservation only when it reduces primary extraction and residual waste in absolute terms while avoiding burden shifting across places, sectors, populations, and ecosystems.
Downloads
References
Afolabi, J.A. & Islam, M.R. (2025). Driving the circular economy in the European Union: Public environmental expenditure, private sector investment, and their synergy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2025.127529
Ambituuni, A., Ajala, O., Schroeder, P. & Oyinlola, M. (2025). Catalysing Environmental Action: a Governance Framework for Enhancing Individual Participation in Sub-Saharan Africa’s Plastic Circular Economy. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-024-02044-7
Bansal, R. & Ansari, Y. (2025). The role of drivers for sustainable development in the electric vehicle adoption: A two-staged structural equation modelling-artificial neural network technique. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2025.200255
Cordoș, N., Duma, I., Moldovanu, D., Todoruț, A. & Barabás, I. (2025). An Overview of Intelligent Transportation Systems in Europe. https://doi.org/10.3390/wevj16070387
Duarte, N., Pereira, C., Grzywińska-Rąpca, M., Kulli, A. & Goci, E. (2025). Consumers’ knowledge and decisions on circularity: Albanian, Polish, and Portuguese perspectives. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-024-05077-4
Georgescu, L.P., Barbuta Misu, N., Antohi, V.M., Fortea, C. & Zlati, M.L. (2025). Approaches and perspectives on the transition to the circular economy in the European Union. https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2025.1533776
González Forastero, Á. (2023). Circular economy in Andalusia: A review of public and non-governmental initiatives. Resources, Conservation & Recycling Advances, 17, 200133. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2023.200133
Granados, M.L. & Adelekan, A. (2026). Towards a Socially Inclusive Circular Economy: Evidence From Social Enterprises in Low- and Middle-Income Countries. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.70940
Gura, K.S., Nica, E., Kliestik, T. & Puime-Guillén, F. (2023). Circular economy in territorial planning strategy: Incorporation in cluster activities and economic zones. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eti.2023.103357
Hassan, M., Cerruti, C. & Gusmerotti, N.M. (2026). Circular economy innovation drivers and the role of quadruple helix stakeholders: a systematic literature review. https://doi.org/10.1108/MEQ-07-2025-0516
Hernández-Romero, I.M., Niño-Caballero, J.C., González, L.T., Pérez-Rodríguez, M., Flores-Tlacuahuac, A. & Montesinos-Castellanos, A. (2024). Waste management optimization with NLP modeling and waste-to-energy in a circular economy. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-69321-7
Iofrida, N., Spada, E., Gulisano, G., De Luca, A.I. & Falcone, G. (2026). The social impacts of circular economy: disclosing epistemological stances and methodological practices. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-024-05438-z
Jakubelskas, U., Skvarciany, V. & Vainoriūtė, V. (2026). The impact of the circular economy on the sustainable development in the EU. https://doi.org/10.15611/aoe.2026.1.11
Kanagaraj, B., Anand, N., Samuvel Raj, R. & Lubloy, E. (2024). Evaluation of mechanical, durability and sustainability performance of geopolymer concrete using sodium silicate waste as source material. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cscm.2024.e03898
Kumar, P. & Jaisuriyan, K. (2026). Biotechnological Integration in Smart Horticulture Production. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781998511679-12
Kumar, R., Gupta, S. & Ur Rehman, U. (2023). Circular Economy a Footstep toward Net Zero Manufacturing: Critical Success Factors Analysis with Case Illustration. https://doi.org/10.3390/su152015071
Kumar, R., Malik, J., Chandhoke, S. & Singh, A. (2024). Circular Economy Practices in Manufacturing Organization: Analysis of Enablers. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-97-3173-2_8
Kumar, R., Phanden, R.K., Kumar, P. & Kumar, A. (2026). Analysis of roadblocks and enablers of net-zero in Indian manufacturing SMEs. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-025-02487-w
Mamun, A., Torst, N. & Sabantina, L. (2023). Advancing towards a Circular Economy in the Textile Industry. https://doi.org/10.3390/ASEC2023-15244
Nicoletti, B. & Appolloni, A. (2025). Artificial Intelligence in Support of Warehousing 5.0 and the EU Green Taxonomy. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-91686-1_9
Pacheco, M.E.T., Mayorga, L.V.L., Parra-Orobio, B.A., Mejia-Parada, C., Alvarez, J., Saavedra-Pasaje, C. & Soto-Paz, J. (2026). Circular Economy in tourism: Challenges and opportunities for a sustainable future. https://doi.org/10.25145/j.pasos.2026.24.026
Pathak, M., Hajoary, P.K. & Garza-Reyes, J.A. (2026). Unpacking the Drivers of Circular Economy in Tourism: An Interpretive Structural Modeling and Argumentative Discourse Analysis. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-026-00797-3
Raimi, B.O. (2026). Effectiveness of reduction, reuse, and recycling (3Rs) strategies in developing economies. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-443-33166-4.00005-7
Sadeghi, M., Fallahpour, M. & Arab, A. (2026). Analyzing circular economy enablers in the Iranian hospital sector: a hybrid group decision-making approach. https://doi.org/10.1080/20476965.2026.2703636
Salim, R., Ech-chihbi, E., Ettahiri, W., Hammouti, B., Rais, Z. & Taleb, M. (2024). Industrial Corrosion Inhibitors: Food Waste as Ideal Substitutes. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-97-1160-4_11
Sanz-Torró, V., Calafat-Marzal, C., Guaita-Martinez, J.M. & Vega, V. (2025). Assessment of European countries’ national circular economy policies. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2024.123835
Sell, L.G., Simioni, F.J., Soares, J.F., Bertol, E. & Coelho Junior, L.M. (2026). Industrial symbiosis and circular economy: Contributions to the development of forest biomass industrial clusters. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2026.103813
Spada, E., Carlucci, D., Cembalo, L., Chinnici, G., D'Amico, M., Falcone, G., Giannoccaro, G., Gulisano, G., Iofrida, N., Stempfle, S. & De Luca, A.I. (2025). Evaluating Circular Strategies for the Resilience of Agri-Food Business: Evidence From the Olive Oil Supply Chain. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.4121
Taouahria, B. (2024). Predicting citizens municipal solid waste recycling intentions in Morocco: The role of community engagement. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wmb.2024.02.008
Tumpa, R.J., Akomea-Frimpong, I., Botchway, B. & Ofori, J.N.A. (2026). Barriers in implementing circular economy principles in public–private partnership smart cities. https://doi.org/10.1108/BEPAM-09-2025-0299
Tung, T.M. (2025). Circular Product Design and Development: Principles, Strategies, and Case Studies. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003538837-8
Zhao, W., Osman, L.H. & Faezah, J.N. (2024). Developing A Conceptual Model of Factors Influencing Express Delivery Packaging Recycling Behaviors of E-Commerce Enterprises in China. https://doi.org/10.59953/paperasia.v40i6b.281
Ćwiklicki, M., Baryła, M., Mirzyńska, A. & Żabiński, M. (2024). Circular economy adoption at the regional level: a neo-institutional perspective. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2024.2374923
Hafizh, M., Ramansyah, F. P., & Maulida, C. Z. (2024). The Effect Of Economic Growth And Inflation On Foreign Direct Investment (Fdi) In Asean Countries. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 3(2), 274-279.
Ilham, R. N., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2026). THE EFFECT OF FINANCIAL ATTITUDE, FINANCIAL KNOWLEDGE AND LOCUS OF CONTROL ON THE PERSONAL FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT BEHAVIOR OF FEB STUDENTS OF MALIKUSSALEH UNIVERSITY. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 5(2), 1157-1165.
Ilham, R. N., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2026). THE EFFECT OF RETURN ON EQUITY, EARNING PER SHARE, AND DEBT TO EQUITY RATIO ON SHARE PRICES OF TECHNOLOGY SECTOR COMPANIES LISTED ON THE INDONESIA STOCK EXCHANGE IN 2020-2024. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 5(2), 1038-1044.
Ilham, R. N., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2024). Financing Efficiency Analysis Using Data Envelopment Analysis (Dea) Approach At Bank Aceh Syariah. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 3(2), 249-254.
Ilham, R. N., Bate'e, M. M., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2026). Phenomenological Study Of Carbon Emission Disclosure, Profitability And Environmental Performance In Improving Stock Returns Of energy Sector Companies In Big Four Asean Countries. Calitatea, 27(212), 509-523.
Juanda, R., Ilham, R. N., Ramansyah, F. P., & Multazam, M. (2024). The Role Of Digital Asset Investment In Country Economic Growth. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 3(2), 211-217.
Mawaddah, I., Ramansyah, F. P., Siregar, P. W. A., Lista, W. M., & Maharani, D. (2026). ANALYSIS OF INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES IN THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS SECTOR IN INDONESIA FROM AN INVESTMENT AND PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT PERSPECTIVE. Global Economics Research and Actual Management, 3(2), 178-189.
Ramansyah, F. P., Salsabila, R., Lubis, F. Y., Jannah, M. M., & Listyaningtias, H. (2025). Analisis Laporan Keuangan PT Essa Industries Indonesia Tbk Tahun 2023. Zona Manajerial: Program Studi Manajemen (S1) Universitas Batam, 15(1), 1-8.
Ramansyah, F. P., Idhami, R., & Saragih, M. M. S. (2025). ENERGY DEMAND, INCENTIVE POLICIES, AND RENEWABLE ENERGY PRODUCTION: EVIDENCE FROM SOUTH AFRICA. Global Economics Research and Actual Management, 2(1), 18-25.
Ramansyah, F. P., Idhami, R., Aryantie, A., & Rizka, L. S. (2025). Analysis of Human Resource Management Strategy at Angkringan D'Legend Coffee UMKM. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 3(4), 397-400.
Ramansyah, F. P., Husaini, H., Jummaini, J., & Wardhiah, W. (2023, December). Determination Of Firm Value In The Consumer Cyclicals Sector Listed On The Indonesia Stock Exchange. In Proceedings of International Conference on Finance Economics and Business (ICOFEB) (Vol. 1, pp. 0033-0033).
Ramansyah, F. P., Salsabila, R., Lubis, F. Y., Jannah, M. M., & Listyaningtias, H. (2025). Analisis Laporan Keuangan PT Essa Industries Indonesia Tbk Tahun 2023. Zona Manajerial: Program Studi Manajemen (S1) Universitas Batam, 15(1), 1-8.
Ramansyah, F. P., Tunnur, M., & Idhami, R. (2025). MINI RESEARCH OF UMKM SURABAYA CHICKEN GREAT RESTAURANT (BUSINESS CAPITAL). Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 3(4), 412-416.
RAMANSYAH, F. P. (2025). DAMPAK PENGUNGKAPAN EMISI KARBON, INOVASI HIJAU, ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL GOVERNANCE (ESG), EKOEFISIENSI, DAN KINERJA LINGKUNGAN TERHADAP NILAI PERUSAHAAN (STUDI EMPIRIS PADA PERUSAHAAN SEKTOR BASIC MATERIAL DAN ENERGY) (Doctoral dissertation, Universitas Malikussaleh).
Mahenrato, V., Hidayat, M. F., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2025). Analysis of Human Resource Management at Nasari Syariah Savings and Loan Cooperative, Lhokseumawe. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 4(1), 401-406.
Multazam, M., Ramansyah, F. P., & Idhami, R. (2024). CARBON TAXITION, ENERGY TRANSITION, AND SOCIAL INEQUALITY: EVIDENCE FROM BRICS COUNTRIES. Global Economics Research and Actual Management, 1(2), 82-90.
Safitri, Y., Ilham, R. N., Syamni, G., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2027). THE EFFECT OF CURRENT RATIO, RETURN ON EQUITY, FIRM SIZE, AND DEBT-TO-EQUITY RATIO ON STOCK PRICES OF COAL SUBSECTOR COMPANIES LISTED ON THE INDONESIA STOCK EXCHANGE DURING THE 2021–2025. Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 5(3), 972-978.
Sinta, I., Ilham, R. N., Multazam, M., & Ramansyah, F. P. (2024). Solvability Ratio To Bond Rating In The Company Pt. Adhi Commuter Properties And Subsidiaries In 2021-2022 Listed On The Indonesian Stock Exchange (BEI). Journal of Accounting Research, Utility Finance and Digital Assets, 2(4), 154-159.
Sinta, I., Ilham, R. N., Muttagien, M., Juanda, R., Ramansyahs, F. P., & RAMANSYAHS, F. P. (2025). The Effect of Working Capital Management and Leverage on the Value of Manufacturing Companies Listed on Big Four ASEAN Country Stock Exchange: Special Report on Simultaneous General Elections. Calitatea, 26(208), 204-213.



